do it: SERVFAIL diagnosis
DNSSEC troubleshooting: is it the signatures?
Step 1: check whether DNSSEC is the cause#
Run the failing query twice, the second time with +cd (checking disabled, RFC 4035 section 3.2.2). Replace NAME with the name that fails.
dig @1.1.1.1 NAME A
dig @1.1.1.1 NAME A +cd| Plain query | With +cd | It is |
|---|---|---|
SERVFAIL | NOERROR | DNSSEC: go to step 2 |
SERVFAIL | SERVFAIL | not isolated: read the EDE (step 2); DNSSEC not ruled out; servfail |
Step 2: read why#
Read the EDE line in the failing answer (RFC 8914). Here a zone broken on purpose:
Asks a deliberately broken zone for its address.
dig @1.1.1.1 dnssec-failed.org AGO SERVFAIL, and an EDE line naming the reason
NO GO NOERROR with an address
DO resolver operator: Check validation is on, nothing validated the chain
| EDE | Means | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| 6, DNSSEC Bogus | a signature does not check out | find the link, step 3 |
| 7, Signature Expired | the signatures ran out | re-sign the zone |
| 9, DNSKEY Missing | the parent's DS matches no key the zone publishes | publish the key, or fix the DS |
| 10, RRSIGs Missing | records came back unsigned where signatures were expected | sign the zone, or remove the DS |
No EDE line in your dig output? Ask over DoH; the Comment field carries it:
curl -s -H 'accept: application/dns-json' 'https://cloudflare-dns.com/dns-query?name=NAME&type=A'Step 3: find the broken link#
Check the chain with delv, which validates every link against its own root key and prints one verdict. On a Mac, use a current delv (brew install bind): the one macOS ships, 9.10.6, prints no crypto support.
delv @1.1.1.1 NAME Adelv prints | Means |
|---|---|
; fully validated | the chain is good; the problem is elsewhere |
;; resolution failed: failure | the chain is broken; add +rtrace to see each fetch |
; unsigned answer | the zone is not signed |
Or draw the whole chain: dnsviz.
See also#
- extended-dns-errors: every EDE code
- dnssec: how the chain works
- ksk-roll-2026: the root key roll
- SERVFAIL diagnosis: the EDE, the same question with +cd, then the chain